The Great Depression: A Diary – Book Review

Benjamin Roth was a lawyer in Youngstown, Ohio during the Great Depression and kept a regular diary of his impressions during the era. The diary was required reading for his son who also became a lawyer at the firm he started, in order to understand what their clients went through. After the recent crash, it has now been published as a book called The Great Depression: A Diary.

The book is primarily a straight transcription of the original handwritten journal, with a few editor’s notes to provide a little additional background when needed. Each entry is dated, and it is very interesting to see the first-person perspective unfold over time. Indeed, imagine a “blog” back then and you’d get this. Roth was not an economist or historian, and simply wrote down what he saw.

Historical Similarities
It is easy to find many similarities between the recession back then and now. The stock market and real estate market boomed, speculation was rampant, and then it all collapsed. Banks were stuck with mortgages that nobody could afford to keep up with, and foreclosures were everywhere. Unemployment was very high, although it was 25% back then as compared to 10% now.

[9/19/32] It looks as tho the Democrats will win because everybody wants a “change”.

Sound familiar?

Roth considered himself a Republican, and did worry a lot about “a shift towards socialism” and inflation always being around the corner. The government did end up spending a lot of money to stimulate the economy, although not exactly the same way as now. On the other hand, many things that seemed like radical changes back then are things that we almost take for granted today – including new institutions like the FDIC to provide bank deposit insurance, the SEC to regulate investments, and even Social Security.

Historical Differences
Throughout the diary, Roth is always talking about how numerous banks failed or re-opened temporarily only to close again due to rapid withdrawals. This led to even the strongest banks putting very tight restrictions on withdrawals (i.e. max 5% of deposits). Without something like the FDIC, people ended up selling their account balances for 40 cents on the dollar because they needed the money immediately or were afraid they’d never see it again.

Personal Finance & Investing
Roth often wrote about personal finance and investing as well. He really like the idea of saving up a lot of cash during boom times, and then investing it all at the “bottom” after a crash, although he gradually seemed to realize that predicting the exact bottom was impossible and that simply holding it for the long term might be more reasonable.

In normal times the average professional man makes just a living and lives up to the limit of his income because he must dress well, etc. In times of depression he not only fails to make a living but has no surplus capital to buy stocks and real estate. I see now how important it is for the professional man to build up a surplus in normal times. […] His practice suffers and he has no chance of rising above the level of the ordinary practitioner who lives from day to day and from hand to mouth.

[5/9/1932] Those men who were wise enough to sell during the boom and then keep their funds liquid in the form of government bonds, etc. were not farsighted enough or patient enough to wait almost three years to re-invest. Most of them re-invested a year or more ago and now find stock prices have sagged to 1/3 of what they were when they thought they were buying bargains.

Of course, back then there was still the CNBC equivalent of various economists and business leaders sharing their “future economic outlook”. Roth recorded their predictions and always seemed to come back with a later follow-up note “…the predictions were wrong.” Some things never change!

If I were to levy a criticism of this book, it would be that it is more of a list of his observations, as opposed to his personal actions. For example, he often mentions how local Bank A or Bank B has failed or is restricting withdrawals. But Roth doesn’t actually share where he keeps his money, if he has moved it due to fear, or if he has had problems withdrawing his own deposits. He doesn’t share his personal investments, even though he records the share prices of many companies regularly. This ends up making the trip to the past a bit more dry than it could have been, but it was still a fun and enlightening trip to take.

Comments

  1. Your comparison on unemployment is apples to oranges. They calculated the unemployment rate differently then than they do now. For example, they now consider people who take part-time work while they are still looking for full-time work as employed, whereas they counted those people as unemployed in the 1930s. Also, the unemployment rate was 25% in 1933, 4 years into the Great Depression – we are only 1 year into this depression.

  2. While the Great Depression is far from analogous to what we are going through now, it’s interesting that the reaction has been much the same.

  3. dirty_dirty says:

    Or maybe we can’t see the forrest from the trees. Could it be that we’re still in this rut and that monetary policy will fail? Only time will tell.

  4. I’m no historian, but it seems to me that a big difference is that back then most people were not living beyond their means. That crash devestated families, individuals, people doing the right thing. Unemployment will hurt some families, but not anywhere near the level it was back then.

    Nobody should have been devestated by this crash. People in retirement shouldn’t have been invested 90% in stocks. People that got wiped out now made foolish choices. If the market was currently at the level it was in 1975 than I’d feel bad, but it’s only a few years off it’s high now.

    The last crash crushed invidividuals, but I think our problem is more of a slow detoriating death. I don’t feel that our country can continue in the direction we are going. It’s like a huge bubble waiting to burst. We are the kings and queens of the world and the rest of the world is supporting our luxoriously lifestyle. It’s got to crash.

  5. Am I the only one who is suspicious of the authenticity of this book? It doesn’t really read like a diary. It makes me wonder if some details were added by the editors.

  6. @Andy – I expressed the same cynicism initially:

    /archives/2008/10/weekend-reading-diary-from-the-great-depression.html

    I guess that is why the publishers sent me this book to review. They also have scanned images of the actual diary, and the language and tone is very consistent. After reading the whole thing, I didn’t see anything suspicious about any certain parts. It’s mainly me picking out certain phrases to spotlight.

  7. Some concerns about authenticity as well. Good it’s been confirmed.

Trackbacks

  1. […] you are willing to read something longer, I recommend The Great Depression: A Diary. 2008/2009 was bad, but things could have been much worse. It’s easy to not appreciate safe […]

Speak Your Mind

*